I’m Carly. I’m 32, a marketing director, a proud dog mom, and someone who’s spent most of her adult life figuring out how to exist in a body that people think they get to comment on.
Let’s not sugarcoat it: I’m fat. Not the kind of “plus-size cute” that magazines occasionally celebrate during diversity month. I’m the kind of fat that makes strangers think they’re qualified to critique my grocery choices. The kind that gets silent stares in waiting rooms and judgmental glances on planes.
Which is exactly why, when I travel alone, I buy two airline seats. Not out of luxury. Not for fun. For peace.
My boyfriend Matt never makes me feel like I take up too much space. When we fly together, he lifts the armrest, lets me lean on him, jokes about who gets the window seat. But this flight—heading solo to a conference in Westlake—was different. I knew I’d be alone in that cabin with strangers and their assumptions.
I boarded early, tucked into my window seat, and flipped up the armrest between my two seats. My space. I’d spent an extra $176 so I wouldn’t have to spend three hours squished between apologies and side-eyes.
That sense of relief lasted exactly five minutes.
“Hey babe! Look, I can sit right next to you instead!” a voice called out behind me.
I glanced up.
There they were: the Couple from Instagram Central Casting. He looked like he bench-pressed before breakfast. She had glossy hair, dramatic lashes, and a voice like a Chardonnay commercial.
They were both eyeing the middle seat like it was a lost lottery ticket.
“Sorry,” I said, polite but firm. “I paid for both of these seats.”
“You bought two seats? For yourself?” the guy said, blinking like he couldn’t compute the concept.
“Yes. For comfort. It’s not available.”
“Come on,” he said with a dismissive wave. “It’s empty. It’s not like it’s reserved for someone else.”
“It’s reserved for me,” I replied.
He laughed like I’d told a great joke, then—uninvited—plopped down in the middle seat. His girlfriend slid into the aisle seat across from him like they’d just pulled off a clever little hack.
“We just want to sit together,” she said sweetly. “It’s not that big of a deal.”
Actually, it was.
He was already pressing into me, his arm brushing mine, his leg claiming space I paid for. The freedom I’d bought was suddenly gone.
“I understand wanting to sit together,” I told them calmly, “but I paid for this seat specifically to avoid this exact situation.”
He rolled his eyes. “Geez, just move over a little. It’s not my fault if you need extra room.”
His girlfriend gave a theatrical sigh. “Oh my god. You’re being such a fat jerk about this.”
Those words landed like a slap. Loud enough for the nearby rows to hear. Loud enough for an older woman across the aisle to look away. Loud enough to make my chest burn.
I could’ve called the flight attendant. Could’ve raised my voice.
But I smiled instead.
“Fine,” I said. “Keep the seat.”
At cruising altitude, I retrieved a crinkly bag of extra-crunchy kettle chips.
“Hope you don’t mind,” I said to Mr. Entitled as I opened the bag right by his ear. “I snack when I fly.”
I stretched out. Not subtly. I reclaimed every inch of the space I paid for. Every time he shifted, I leaned in. Tablet angled wide. Elbows out. Water bottle retrieved with a theatrical jostle.
Twenty minutes in, he was clearly miserable. His girlfriend kept sending dagger eyes my way.
“Can you not move around so much?” he finally grumbled.
I turned to him, feigning surprise. “I’m just trying to get comfortable. In my seats.”
He snapped, “You’re in one seat.”
“No,” I said cheerfully, “I’m in one and a half. The half you’re occupying? That one cost me extra.”
He hit the call button.
The flight attendant appeared, all brisk professionalism. “How can I help you?”
“This woman keeps elbowing me,” he complained. “She’s spreading out, eating in my face—”
The attendant turned to me. I raised two fingers.
“I paid for both these seats.”
A few taps on her tablet, and she nodded. “She’s right. Sir, 14A and 14B are both hers. I’ll need you to return to your assigned seat.”
“What? This is ridiculous!”
“Your seat is 22C, sir.”
Muttering, red-faced, he stood up and stalked to the back. His girlfriend followed with a dramatic hair flip.
Before they were even out of sight, I leaned back and exhaled.
Then I pressed the call button again.
“Yes?” the flight attendant returned, her tone still polite.
“Earlier, the woman who just left called me a ‘fat jerk.’ Loudly. I wanted to report it.”
She blinked. Then nodded. “Thank you for telling me. That absolutely qualifies as harassment. Would you be willing to submit a formal complaint after the flight?”
“Gladly.”
When we landed, they tried one more stunt—arguing with another flight attendant about switching seats mid-flight. They ended up separated for the remainder of the journey, fuming.
As we disembarked, I turned to face them one last time.
“Next time,” I said clearly, “think twice before insulting someone and stealing their seat. Some of us are just trying to get through the day.”
An older woman behind me whispered, “Good for you.”
I filed the complaint.
Three days later, I got an email from the airline.
“After review of the incident on Flight 2419, we’ve noted this in the involved passengers’ profiles for future reference. In addition, we’ve added 10,000 bonus miles to your account in recognition of your patience.”
I forwarded the email to Matt.
His reply?
“That’s my girl. Taking up space and taking no crap.”
And here’s the thing: I spent so many years trying to make myself small. Quieter. Easier.
But I paid for that seat. I deserved that space. And so do you.
Next time someone tries to shame you out of your comfort, remember: the price of peace is not up for negotiation—especially at 35,000 feet.