But that confidence is exactly where most people go wrong. The widely accepted answer is eight holes, and reaching it requires looking past the obvious damage to the shirt’s basic construction, since the visible rips alone don’t tell the whole story.

Starting With the Shirt Itself

Before counting any tears, the puzzle asks you to count the holes already built into every T-shirt. That means one for the neck, one at the bottom hem, and one for each armhole.

Added together, those standard openings give you four holes before the visible rips even enter the picture. It’s an easy detail to skip past, since we rarely think of a shirt’s normal shape as a set of holes.

The Trick Hidden in the Tears

The real twist lies in how the visible rips are meant to be read. Each tear doesn’t just pass through the front of the fabric, it continues through to the back as well.

That means every tear actually creates two separate openings in the garment, not one. With two tears accounted for this way, that’s four additional holes layered on top of the original four.

Four from the shirt’s normal openings, plus four from the tears passing through both layers of fabric, brings the total to eight.

Why So Many People Get It Wrong

The puzzle’s difficulty has nothing to do with complicated math. It comes down to a single overlooked assumption: treating each tear as a single hole instead of two.

If the tears were imagined as affecting only the front of the shirt, the same counting method would produce six instead of eight. That two-hole gap is the entire trick, and it’s where most incorrect guesses come from.

In the end, the puzzle isn’t really testing arithmetic. It’s testing whether you questioned your first assumption, since the details people overlook are often the ones that change the answer completely.