After the tragic discovery of Gene Hackman, his wife Betsy Arakawa, and one of their dogs in their Santa Fe home, speculation surrounding their deaths quickly spread. Many questioned whether the circumstances were truly accidental or if something more sinister had occurred. Now, a forensic expert has suggested a heartbreaking theory that points to a tragic accident rather than foul play.

The devastating news shook Hollywood and fans alike on February 26, 2025. Hackman, 95, and Arakawa, 65, were found lifeless in their residence, with one of their dogs also deceased. The two remaining dogs, however, were found alive. The scene inside their home presented a puzzling set of details that left authorities searching for answers.

When law enforcement arrived at the home, they noted that the bathroom door near the entrance was open. Arakawa was found on the floor inside, a black space heater nearby, and an open prescription bottle with scattered pills on the bathroom counter. Not far from her, in a closet within the same bathroom, the body of a German Shepherd was discovered.

Upon further inspection of the home, Hackman was located in the mudroom. His cane and sunglasses were found on the ground beside him. Both he and his wife appeared to have collapsed suddenly, showing signs of decomposition.

Authorities quickly ruled out foul play, citing the absence of any visible blunt force trauma or signs of forced entry. Santa Fe County Sheriff Adan Mendoza confirmed that the couple had been deceased for an extended period before being discovered. Hackman’s pacemaker recorded its last heartbeat on February 17, providing investigators with a likely timeframe for his passing.

Initial speculation centered around carbon monoxide poisoning, given the sudden and simultaneous nature of their deaths. However, after thorough testing, the Santa Fe City Fire Department ruled out this possibility, finding no traces of the toxic gas in the home.

Forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden, former chief medical examiner in New York City, has since put forth a theory regarding the tragic sequence of events that led to their passing. He believes that Hackman likely suffered a fatal heart attack. His pacemaker, which monitors heart activity and regulates pulse rates, recorded a final event consistent with cardiac arrest. Hackman’s advanced age and history of coronary artery disease made him particularly vulnerable.

Baden suggests that Arakawa was alive when her husband collapsed and likely rushed to retrieve his blood pressure medication from the bathroom. In her haste, she may have spilled the pills, slipped, and struck her head on the way down. The space heater, found near her head, may have played a role in the fatal injury. If she suffered internal bleeding or a traumatic brain injury, she may have lost consciousness and died before she could reach her husband.

Pills scattered on the counter near her body support the theory that she had found the medication but was unable to return to her husband in time. This tragic series of events may have resulted in both of their deaths, neither able to help the other in their final moments.

The presence of their deceased dog added another layer of mystery to the case. The animal was found inside a closet within the bathroom, leading some to speculate whether it had died due to the same unknown cause. However, Baden believes the dog’s death was likely due to dehydration and starvation, as it may have been trapped without food or water for over a week.

The couple’s two remaining dogs were discovered alive on the property. One was near Arakawa’s body inside the bathroom, while the other was outside the residence. The contrasting fates of the three animals suggest that the deceased dog may have been inadvertently locked in the bathroom closet, unable to escape after its owners passed away.

Authorities initially misidentified the deceased dog, causing confusion among those close to the couple. Reports first stated that Bear, the couple’s German Shepherd, had died, but later it was confirmed that their other dog, Zinna, a 12-year-old Australian Kelpie mix, was the one found in the closet. Bear and their third dog, Nikita, were taken into the care of a local animal shelter following the incident.

Sheriff Mendoza acknowledged the mix-up, explaining that investigators do not frequently deal with canines and may have misidentified the breed. The correction, while seemingly minor, was significant for those who knew the couple and their pets.

Despite the initial confusion and widespread speculation, Baden’s theory presents a heartbreaking but plausible explanation. What appeared to be a mysterious and suspicious case may have simply been a tragic accident, one in which two people who deeply loved each other met their end in a series of devastating misfortunes.

For those mourning the loss of Hackman and Arakawa, this explanation offers a painful but understandable resolution. Their final moments, though tragic, reflect the deep connection they shared—a love so strong that in life and death, they remained inseparable.